Mushrooms Growing in Your Garden? Are They Dangerous?

Mushrooms Growing in Your Garden? Are They Dangerous?

Many gardeners rush to remove mushrooms when they spot them in their garden. But these fascinating fungi actually send important signals about your garden's health and should not be so hastily removed.


Mushrooms represent just the visible portion of a big underground network that plays a significant role in soil health. The soil's ecosystem contains beneficial fungi that transform organic matter into plant-usable nutrients. The underground networks stretch deep into the soil and help create stronger plant roots while improving water uptake.


What Mushrooms In Your Garden Really Mean


Many gardeners worry when they spot mushrooms in their soil. The truth is these fungal fruiting bodies rarely cause problems. They actually signal a thriving, nutrient-rich environment that helps your plants grow better in many ways.


The mushrooms that mysteriously pop up in your garden soil tell a story about the hidden world below. These fungi aren't like pesky weeds - they're actually signs of a thriving ecosystem right under your feet.


Garden mushrooms usually signal something good. These fungi show your soil has enough organic matter and a bustling community of microbes. Nature uses mushrooms to tell us, "this is good soil." The fungi's presence points to soil with the perfect mix of moisture, organic materials, and helpful microorganisms that work together. So when mushrooms appear, you can see the results of all the invisible work happening in your garden.


The mushrooms you see are just the "fruit" of something much bigger. A vast network of tiny fungal threads called mycelium spreads beneath the surface. This hidden structure can stretch across many feet or acres. Scientists found that there was a single mycelium network in Michigan that covers over 40 acres, weighs about 112 tons, and has lived for at least 1,500 years.


Fungi help plants absorb more nutrients and water by expanding their root surface. As they break down organic matter, mushrooms release important nutrients back into the soil. This process boosts soil fertility and helps lower excess carbon in the atmosphere.

When Mushrooms Might Indicate Problems



Mushrooms can be good for your garden, but they can also show problems that need fixing. If your garden has too much moisture, it can cause mushrooms to grow. This may mean you are overwatering or that you have drainage issues. You can usually solve this by adjusting your watering schedule.


Keep in mind that mushrooms in the garden help your plants 90% of the time. In most cases, the best choice is to leave them alone.


Benefits Of Mushrooms Growing In The Garden

Garden mushrooms may look simple, but they do much more than break down matter. They build the foundation for your garden's health and success.


  • Nutrient cycling: Mushrooms turn complex organic materials into nutrients that plants can easily use. As they decompose matter, they release essential elements like nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium into the soil.
  • Water retention: Research shows that soil with mycorrhizal fungal hyphae holds more water that plants can use. This means your garden soil keeps more moisture during dry spells. The fungal networks create pores that are much larger than the fungi themselves. This better soil structure helps water flow in heavy soils and increases water storage in sandy soils that dry quickly.
  • Disease suppression: Soil that has a lot of fungi can reduce diseases like Fusarium wilt by 67-74%. Fungi produce substances that fight diseases, compete for food, and help plants protect themselves. Trichoderma fungi help plants deal with stress from drought, salt, and heavy metals.
  • Root development: Research shows that plants with mycorrhizal fungi grow bigger and develop longer roots with more branches and surface area. This partnership allows plants to access more soil and nutrients while using less energy.

Safe Management Of Garden Mushrooms

Most garden mushrooms should be left alone. These fungi usually go away by themselves as weather changes bring sunshine, drier conditions, or cold temperatures. The vast majority of mushroom species that show up in the garden will only be visible for a few days or a week.


Also, removing the physical fruiting body doesn't actually remove the mushroom from the garden. The mycelium is still in the soil, and the mushrooms will fruit again when the conditions are right. This may be in a few weeks or next year.


Some situations do call for mushroom removal. If there is a danger to children or pets, remove the fruiting bodies immediately. Most garden mushrooms are not poisonous, so don't panic. However, if you have little ones or pets that may get at them, it's best to remove them.


Identifying mushrooms creates the biggest problem - even experts sometimes can't tell harmless ones from toxic species. Make sure to teach children never to eat anything from the garden without asking an adult first.


Common Garden Mushrooms


Garden mushrooms come in many shapes, sizes, and colors because there are so many types of fungi. To identify what is growing in your soil, pay close attention to specific details. 


First, check the underside of the mushroom cap. Look for gills or pores and notice their color, spacing, and how they connect to the stem. Next, examine the stem. Check its color, texture, and whether it is solid or hollow inside.


A spore print is a great way to help identify mushrooms. Place a fresh mushroom cap on paper and wait several hours to see the spore color—many field guides use this feature to classify species.


Field mushrooms (Agaricus campestris) love to pop up in lawns and grassy areas. These edible mushrooms look like the button mushrooms you'd find in grocery stores. Watch out for the yellow-staining mushroom (Agaricus xanthodermus) that looks similar but causes stomach problems in many people.


Fly agaric (Amanita muscaria) with its red cap and white spots grows near birch or spruce trees. This mushroom is poisonous.


Fairy ring mushrooms (Marasmius oreades) create perfect circles in lawn areas. These fungi start from one spot, usually a buried tree stump, and spread outward as they feed on nutrients. This mushroom is not poisonous but is not edible, either.
The cap measures 0.8 to 2.4 inches across and can be dome-shaped or flat with a slight bump in the center. When it is young, it's light tan, but it darkens with age. The stem is white, slender, tough, and about 1.2 to 2.8 inches tall. The gills are spaced out, cream-colored, and do not attach directly to the stem.


Inky caps have bell-shaped caps 1 to 3 inches across. As they grow older, the caps start to break down into a black, ink-like substance, which is how they got their name. The gills are white at first but quickly turn black. These mushrooms have thin, fragile stems that can reach up to 6 inches tall and usually have a ring near the base.


Inky caps grow in urban and suburban areas, including lawns, gardens, and disturbed soils. They grow in groups near rotting wood, compost piles, or buried wood. Some species of inky caps are toxic, while others are safe to eat.


The false parasol (Chlorophyllum molybdites) is a large mushroom commonly found in lawns and gardens, particularly in mulched areas. Its cap is white to grayish-brown and measures 4 to 10 inches in diameter. The cap has brownish scales. The thick, white stem can grow up to 8 inches tall and has a ring near the top. One key identifying feature of this mushroom is its green spore print. This mushroom is poisonous and should not be eaten, as it can cause serious stomach problems.
Back to blog